Sikh Segregation Ends at MTA

 

June 1, 2012 (New York, New York) –  In a historic victory for religious freedom, Sikh and Muslim transit workers settled a federal lawsuit yesterday challenging a post 9/11 policy which segregated them out of public view.  As a result of the settlement, Sikh and Muslim workers may now wear their religious headdress freely --- as they did before 9/11 --- without fear of segregation or discipline.

At issue in the seven year old federal case was whether New York’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) could force Sikh and Muslim workers to either brand their religious headdress with its logo --- while not requiring the same headwear branding of other workers --- or force them to work out of public view.                   

The MTA cited security concerns after 9/11 as the reason for its “brand or segregate” policy. The MTA insisted the new policy was necessary despite Sikh and Muslim employees working successfully at MTA for decades without such a policy in place.

"I am relieved that the policy of branding or segregating Sikh or Muslim workers is coming to an end,” said plaintiff Sat Hari Singh (aka Kevin Harrington), a Sikh train operator. “The MTA honored me  for driving my train in reverse away from the towers on 9/11 and leading passengers to safety. They called me a 'hero of 9/11.'  I didn't have a corporate logo on my turban on 9/11. This policy made no sense. It was driven by fear. I’m glad it has come to an end.”

“I worked as a station agent for more than a decade before 9/11. My turban never interfered with my work in any way. I’m happy that I can do my job now without having to worry about this policy hanging over me,” said plaintiff Inderjit Singh, a Sikh station agent.

See historic photos here!

A Note of Thanks
The Sikh Coalition thanks the United States Justice Department and its Civil Rights Division for their tireless work in this case. The Department of Justice led the litigation and expended thousands of attorney hours on the case.  This victory for religious freedom would not be possible without them. The Coalition also thanks its co-counsel Center for Constitutional Rightsand Bhalla & Cho LLC, and in particularly attorneys Shayana Kadidal, Ravinder Singh Bhalla, and Anjana Samant. Most importantly, the Coalition salutes and applauds Sikh train operator Sat Hari Singh (aka Kevin Harrington) and Sikh Station Agents Inderjit Singh, Jatinder Singh Attari, Brijinder Singh Gill, Trilok Singh Arora, and Satinder Singh Arora for standing up to the MTA and standing up for all of our rights.

Case Timeline:

  • May 2005: Sikh Coalition files Charge of Discrimination with Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) on behalf of Sikh subway conductor.

 

  • July 2005: Coalition files Charges of Discrimination with the EEOC on behalf of 5 Sikh station agents who were told to brand their turbans with the MTA logo. Sikh Coalition, Center for Constitutional Rights, and Bhalla & Cho LLC are co-counsel for Sikh subway conductor and Sikh station agents.
  • July 2005: Coalition files lawsuit in federal court on behalf of Sikh subway conductor.

 

  • September 2005: Coalition files lawsuit in federal court on behalf of Sikh station agents.
  • July 2008: U.S. Justice Department and plaintiffs' counsel engage in discovery and preparation of summary judgment papers. U.S. Justice Department deposes and defends the depositions of more than a dozen witnesses and is able to obtain thousands of documents on the MTA's policies and practices.
  • March 2009: MTA files motion to dismiss the Justice Department's case. Justice Department files briefs in opposition.
  • June 2009:  27 New York City Council Members organized by the Sikh Coalition call on MTA to end turban-branding policy in a letter to the MTA.
  • September 2010: Judge Sandra Towns denies MTA's motion in its entirety.
  • May 2012: Parties engage in approximately half a dozen settlement negotiation sessions with Magistrate Judge presiding and ultimately seek help of federal mediator in resolving outstanding concerns.
  • May 2012: Parties enter into settlement agreement ending case.

 

Read the coverage: 

  • alt

  • alt   

  • alt

  •  

    alt

 

 

Recent Videos

Profile Information

Application afterLoad: 0.000 seconds, 0.38 MB
Application afterInitialise: 0.054 seconds, 3.87 MB
Application afterRoute: 0.114 seconds, 10.04 MB
Application afterDispatch: 0.239 seconds, 16.01 MB
Application afterRender: 0.401 seconds, 17.44 MB

Memory Usage

18410424

18 queries logged

  1. SELECT *
      FROM scj_session
      WHERE session_id = '9b00c7vtbpjg31948knq4ikep0'
  2. DELETE
      FROM scj_session
      WHERE ( TIME < '1436233499' )
  3. SELECT *
      FROM scj_session
      WHERE session_id = '9b00c7vtbpjg31948knq4ikep0'
  4. INSERT INTO `scj_session` ( `session_id`,`time`,`username`,`gid`,`guest`,`client_id` )
      VALUES ( '9b00c7vtbpjg31948knq4ikep0','1436237099','','0','1','0' )
  5. SELECT *
      FROM scj_components
      WHERE parent = 0
  6. SELECT folder AS TYPE, element AS name, params
      FROM scj_plugins
      WHERE published >= 1
      AND access <= 0
      ORDER BY ordering
  7. SELECT id, title, alias
      FROM scj_jumi
      WHERE published = 1
  8. SELECT m.*, c.`option` AS component
      FROM scj_menu AS m
      LEFT JOIN scj_components AS c
      ON m.componentid = c.id
      WHERE m.published = 1
      ORDER BY m.sublevel, m.parent, m.ordering
  9. SELECT template
      FROM scj_templates_menu
      WHERE client_id = 0
      AND (menuid = 0 OR menuid = 581)
      ORDER BY menuid DESC
      LIMIT 0, 1
  10. SELECT a.*, u.name AS author, u.usertype, cc.title AS category, s.title AS SECTION, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(a.alias) THEN CONCAT_WS(":", a.id, a.alias) ELSE a.id END AS slug, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(cc.alias) THEN CONCAT_WS(":", cc.id, cc.alias) ELSE cc.id END AS catslug, g.name AS groups, s.published AS sec_pub, cc.published AS cat_pub, s.access AS sec_access, cc.access AS cat_access  
      FROM scj_content AS a
      LEFT JOIN scj_categories AS cc
      ON cc.id = a.catid
      LEFT JOIN scj_sections AS s
      ON s.id = cc.SECTION
      AND s.scope = "content"
      LEFT JOIN scj_users AS u
      ON u.id = a.created_by
      LEFT JOIN scj_groups AS g
      ON a.access = g.id
      WHERE a.id = 645
      AND (  ( a.created_by = 0 )    OR  ( a.state = 1
      AND ( a.publish_up = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_up <= '2015-07-07 02:45:00' )
      AND ( a.publish_down = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_down >= '2015-07-07 02:45:00' )   )    OR  ( a.state = -1 )  )
  11. UPDATE scj_content
      SET hits = ( hits + 1 )
      WHERE id='645'
  12. SELECT a.alias
      FROM scj_sections AS a, scj_content AS b  
      WHERE (b.id = 645  
      AND a.id = b.sectionid)
  13. SELECT catid
      FROM scj_content
      WHERE id = 645
  14. SELECT id, title, module, POSITION, content, showtitle, control, params
      FROM scj_modules AS m
      LEFT JOIN scj_modules_menu AS mm
      ON mm.moduleid = m.id
      WHERE m.published = 1
      AND m.access <= 0
      AND m.client_id = 0
      AND ( mm.menuid = 581 OR mm.menuid = 0 )
      ORDER BY POSITION, ordering
  15. SELECT name,created
      FROM scj_tag_term
      ORDER BY created DESC
      LIMIT 0, 25
  16. SELECT sectionid
      FROM scj_content
      WHERE id=645
  17. SELECT s.*  
      FROM scj_sections AS s
      WHERE s.scope = "content"
      AND s.access <= 0
      AND (s.id=9)
      AND s.id=9
      AND s.published = 1
      ORDER BY s.id ASC
      LIMIT 0, 3
  18. SELECT a.*,  CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(a.alias) THEN CONCAT_WS(":", a.id, a.alias) ELSE a.id END AS slug, CASE WHEN CHAR_LENGTH(cc.alias) THEN CONCAT_WS(":", cc.id, cc.alias) ELSE cc.id END AS catslug
      FROM scj_content AS a
      INNER JOIN scj_categories AS cc
      ON cc.id = a.catid
      INNER JOIN scj_sections AS s
      ON s.id = a.sectionid
      WHERE a.state = 1
      AND ( a.publish_up = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_up <= '2015-07-07 02:45:00' )
      AND ( a.publish_down = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_down >= '2015-07-07 02:45:00' )
      AND s.id > 0
      AND a.access <= 0
      AND s.published = 1
      AND a.sectionid = 9
      ORDER BY a.created DESC
      LIMIT 0, 3

Language Files Loaded

Untranslated Strings Diagnostic

None

Untranslated Strings Designer

None